Is texting worse that watching sitcoms?

Is texting worse that watching sitcoms? Let's face it: Teenagers spend hours texting, socializing on Facebook and playing video games. And it's driving their parents nuts.

Sure, there are real dangers associated with all this screen time — everything from cyberbullying to couch-potato obesity. Not to mention driving while texting, shortened attention spans and Internet porn.

But many of today's parents spent hours as kids sitting in front of screens too — only they were TV screens.

Which raises an interesting question: Is Facebook really worse for teenagers' brains than the mindless reruns of "Gilligan's Island" and "The Brady Bunch" that their parents consumed growing up?

But research has shown that the more time kids spend in front of screens — whether it's TV or instant-messaging — the worse their school performance. "That doesn't mean it's true for every kid, but it makes sense, that for every hour a kid is playing video games, it's an hour that they're not doing homework or reading or exploring or creating," said Douglas Gentile, a child psychologist and associate professor at Iowa State University in Ames, Iowa.

Gentile calls this the "displacement hypothesis. If screen time is displacing doing their homework, that's bad. But if their homework is done, well, so what?"

Gentile, who admits that his own teenager crossed the "9,000 texts in one month barrier" last summer, acknowledged that parents are struggling to adjust to a world in which kids would rather look at words on a cell phone screen than have a conversation.

Watching TV as a family, as mindless as that experience can be, is now regarded with nostalgia by parents. If your kid is sitting in the living room watching "American Idol," you can plop on the sofa with them, and "it's a shared experience," Gentile said. But if they're texting or video-chatting with a friend from school, "it's a private experience. It's like they're whispering secrets. And we find it rude."

Patti Rowlson, a mother of two in Everson, Wash., says this "has been a topic of discussion in our house for years now." She and her husband started out limiting TV time when their kids were little, but "then technology crept in. Cell phones, laptop computers, iPods with Wi-Fi. We, as parents, were no longer in control of screen time because we could not even tell when they were using it."

Recounting a struggle that will sound familiar to many parents, Rowlson said that at first, she and her husband imposed limits on tech use.

"There were battles and even groundings," along with the confiscation of iPods, she said. "We were constantly policing and the kids were constantly getting in trouble. We were trying to fight for the old ways, and it was causing a lot of stress and tension in the family. It was ridiculous. So we loosened up. And it's made everybody happier. We were fighting something that you can't hold back. It's how they communicate with their peers."

What's been the result? Two good kids, she said. "In the end I'm not sure if having boundaries early on helped them or made no difference at all."

The explosion in teen screen time is well-documented. A recent Associated Press-mtvU poll found that one-third of college students use computers, cell phones or gaming consoles for six or more hours daily. A Kaiser Family Foundation study published in January found that total media use among 8- to 18-year-olds, including TV, music, computers, video games, print and movies has increased from six hours, 21 minutes daily in 2004 to seven hours, 38 minutes in 2009.

"Try waking a teenager in the morning and the odds are good that you'll find a cell phone tucked under their pillow," the Kaiser report said.

The Kaiser study also found that the more time kids spend with media, the lower their grades and levels of personal contentment are.

Gentile said the impact of screen time on school work can be mitigated by what he calls "protective factors." Those might include good teachers and a high-performing school, love of reading, coming from a family where education is valued, and exposure to experiences that are culturally and intellectually enriching. "If you had all these protective factors," said Gentile, "then that one little risk factor (screen time), who cares?"

He added that surprisingly, the amount of time kids spend watching TV has not declined precipitously with the popularity of computers and gaming, but "they don't pay nearly the attention (to TV) that they used to." The TV might be on, but "they're also instant-messaging, they're on Facebook, they're texting."

One thing parents should worry about, Gentile said, is the way electronic devices encourage multitasking.

"Multitasking is not really good for anyone," he said. "Your reflexes speed up, you're quicker to look over your shoulder and notice little noises or lights. This is not what they need when they get to the classroom and you're supposed to ignore the kid next to you. Scanning to see when the next message comes, this may not be good for kids. The more distractions you have, the worse your performance is." Getting kids to turn off their phones, iPods, and computers in order to concentrate on homework and reading, he said, "I think that's a fight worth having."

Bottom line: Never mind that your kid is spending two hours on Facebook each night. As long as they do their homework without texting in between math problems, it's probably no better or worse than the hours you spent watching "Star Trek."

 

Share on Facebook

 

- Posted on October 28, 2010

I think that if parents didn't want there kids to be on their phones or face books all the time, then they should take them away or at least tell them to take a break and do something other than sit on the couch and be texting or commenting on a friends status. Also if the parents wanted them to other things with their lives other than testing or commenting, they shouldn't let them have face books or phones its their fault for saying yes to giving there kids the things that drive them crazy.

Every kid could admit that they are OBSESSED with texting. I will admit myself that I do send probably more than 200 texts a day and that I do put my cell under my pillow at night and text till one in the morning, but would you rather have to pull your kid off the T.V every time you want them to do their homework, or would you rather let them text between every chapter in your book or every 2 math problems? Gentile has a point. If you argue with your child to turn off their cell or iPod, you're just asking for a fight. That's why I think texting is way better and more efficient than watching T.V all day!

epic......just epic......well in my opinion anyway.....that's my kind of life! anyone that dosn't do this is missing out on life.. :D other people might not COMPLETELYA SUPPORT this but in my opinion its awesome.

I can admit that I keep my cellphone under on pillow at night, but when it comes to homework, I will put my phone away and do it alone in our office. I do this in order to make sure I do all the work and that it is done right. When reading this article, many things stood out to me. For example, the Rowlson’s family has a limit on TV time. That stood out to me because my parents never set a limit for how long we watched TV because their thoughts were that as long as our homework was done we could watch TV. If we didn’t finish our homework the TV was turned off until it was done. As a direct result, we learned that homework is more important than watching the newest Gossip Girl episode. I had always thought that multitasking was a good thing. After reading this, I realized that by multitasking in class probably does me no good. I agree with what Douglas Gentile says about every hour a kid is watching TV there is an hour not spent doing homework. That makes a lot of sense when you think about it. If someone is going to spend an hour doing something way do it on something like watching TV when someone could be doing homework of reading or some other productive activity.

I admit that texting and facebook can get pretty distracting when it comes to having to do school work. It makes procrastinating that much easier expecally when you're having like a conversation with someone it could drag on for hours and those hours you could've been doing school work. It all depends on the person though, some people know how to limit themselves when texting and facebooking but some don't, and those who don't can easily fall back in school because of it.

"I think that if parents didn't want there kids to be on their phones or face books all the time, then they should take them away or at least tell them to take a break and do something other than sit on the couch and be testing or commenting on a friends status. also if the parents wanted them to other things with their lives other than testing or commenting, they shouldn't let them have face books or phones its their fault for saying yes to giving there kids the things that drive them crazy."

I think texting is about the same as watching t.v. on your phone. It can become addicting to some teens texting is all around the world now and you can get video games on your phone and the t.v. and the music and touchable screens too. I think teens should not be addicted to texting because then once you do it it's like you can't stop doing it. Because teens like texting you don't have to hear the persons voice you just have to type words. It's easier to text somebody then it is to call you can get ahold of people faster if you text them chances are they are going to respond back in a five minutes time period.

Texting is really not bad, everybody does it event parents. And as long as you get everything done whats so bad about playing mindless video games. I do not think that the more time in front of a screen, big or small will affect your grades if you are doing the work and paying attention. I do agree that the time in front of the screens makes you jerky and short-attention spanned but we are kids so why does it matter. Other than the fact that we are all going to have Carpel Tunnel Syndrome there is nothing wrong with texting.

Texting isn't THAT bad. Everyone does it, even parents. They do have a point because most kids do text a lot and spend hours on Facebook. If they think that this is such a bad problem, why don't our parents just limit our time for them? Complaining isn't going to do any good...

Yes you are right I don't think texting is that bad but it can be bad if you have an addiction to texting and you can't stop then texting becomes a problem. I know how texting is I have been doing it for a long time my whole family has unlimited texting so we all text back and forth, even my parents do it and they think teens are worse with texting i odn't think so I think adults and teens are about the same with texting. Yes complaining does no good when it comes to texting on the phones. I don't think parents should limit a teens texting because all the teens have fun with the texting they can have a conversation through texting that way they don't talk about the subject out loud.